שיטת רש"י בענין בסיס
We discuss here the comments of Rashi with regard to בסיס. Rashi says it is muttar to shake off the covering from a pot if it is half uncovered, since you are not moving the muktzah.Tosfos asks, what difference does it make that you are not moving the muktzah. The pot itself is muktzah, since it is a בסיס. In addition, Rashi seems to contradict himself. He himself writes that if the pot is totally covered it is muktzah because it is a בסיס. What difference does it make if the pot is covered or not with regard to בסיס? We present here five possible explanations. Includes the comments of the Rashba, Rabbeinu Zerachya Halevy (Baal Hamaor), Rabbeinu Tam, Or Zarua, Maginei Shlomo, Maharsha, Rav Akiva Eiger, Beis Meir, Mekor Baruch, Pri Megadim, Ohr Sameach, and others.
We discuss here the comments of Rashi with regard to בסיס. Rashi says it is muttar to shake off the covering from a pot if it is half uncovered, since you are not moving the muktzah.Tosfos asks, what difference does it make that you are not moving the muktzah. The pot itself is muktzah, since it is a בסיס. In addition, Rashi seems to contradict himself. He himself writes that if the pot is totally covered it is muktzah because it is a בסיס. What difference does it make if the pot is covered or not with regard to בסיס? We present here five possible explanations. Includes the comments of the Rashba, Rabbeinu Zerachya Halevy (Baal Hamaor), Rabbeinu Tam, Or Zarua, Maginei Shlomo, Maharsha, Rav Akiva Eiger, Beis Meir, Mekor Baruch, Pri Megadim, Ohr Sameach, and others.